Controversies Surrounding Various Forms Of Adoptions
A pre-adoption psychological evaluation is invaluable in making sure that mother and father and adoptees will fit well together and develop into a loving family. Adoption is the practice of assuming parental duties towards another who is not of immediate kin. It has seen a decline in recent years, a fact which sociologists surmise may well be attributed to the invention of the birth control pill as well as the increasingly widespread acceptance of illegitimacy and alternative family arrangements. Thus, adoption is no longer a straightforward matter of “Christian charity,” as the phrase goes, nor, as in ancient and even not-so-ancient times, one of apprenticeship or indentured servitude.
The cultural institution of adoption is even now evolving within the United States, but the pre-adoption psychological evaluation is a practice which is becoming increasingly the norm. Whereas it was once in effect on par with indentured servitude or at very best a period of apprenticeship, after the Second World War the sentimental aspects of adoption have become recognized as its standard Raîson D’être. On the other hand, concerned activists have been challenging adoptions on three fronts: open versus sealed adoptions, cross-racial adoptions, and adoption by homosexuals.
Open adoptions are increasingly becoming the norm, with many states recognizing that the right to know of adoptees trumps any privacy concerns of the biological mother and father, who occasionally wish to remain anonymous. Sealed adoptions are still widespread, but the emphasis now is on preserving families if feasible, or at least preserving familial connections as a second-best alternative. Indeed, no less an authority than the New York Foundling Hospital, which was a leading force in establishing adoption norms and best practices in the United States, including the innovation of sealed adoptions, is now staunchly on the side of open adoptions and maintaining biological ties and contact.
The matters of cross-racial adoptions and, in particular, adoption by homosexuals nevertheless involve considerable controversy, where the pre-adoption psychological evaluation may possibly be politicized or otherwise misused. An emphasis on placing kids in families of a similar ethnic or racial background is gaining momentum, though by no means is it the recommended approach yet.
As a response, however, quite a few adoptive parents have grown to be a lot more sensitive about such concerns and even encourage their adopted youngsters to indulge in their ethnic roots and heritage. Adoptions by homosexuals are much more problematic in the United States, but high-profile cases such as those involved beloved celebrities have at least~ made the issue a respectable one for open discussion.